In this episode of Meet the Manager I spoke with Evan Metcalf, Executive Director of Savana, a Sydney-based start-up that runs an active ETF using algorithms instead of a star stock picker. Evan spent about a decade at ETF Securities and Global X, including as CEO of Global X Australia, and has been involved in around 50 ETF launches. In October, AirTree Ventures co-founder Daniel Petre made a personal investment in Savana, alongside its existing backers (Savana announcement).
We covered a lot: why active ETFs are booming, how Savana picks undervalued US small companies, and the "wisdom of the crowd". But the part I found most useful was something most investors never think about: how an active ETF gets priced on the ASX when the fund doesn't show you everything it owns. Each button below jumps the video to that part of the conversation.
1. Why start a new ETF provider now?
Evan's view is that the index (passive) side of the market has become crowded. He described launching a defence technology ETF at Global X, only to see Betashares, VanEck and Global X all launch near-identical funds within about two weeks of each other. Two things stood out to him: ETFs were becoming simply the wrapper people prefer, and active managers were starting to use that wrapper.
“We're a technology-first manager. We don't have a star stock picker… We use algorithms, we use data, and we use that to build portfolios.”Evan Metcalf, Executive Director, Savana
2. Active vs passive isn't black and white
A true passive ETF tracks a broad benchmark, like the ASX 200, the S&P 500 or MSCI World. But Evan made a good point: a "passive" semiconductor ETF is still a very active decision about what goes in your portfolio. Thematic and smart beta ETFs are really active ideas with rules around them.
Active managers have struggled because many have been more expensive than index funds and haven't consistently beaten them. That's why picking the right active manager matters so much, and why active ETFs need to show they can add value after fees.
3. Active ETFs are taking off
In the US, Evan said, around 90% of new ETF launches are now active, and they take around 40% of new money. Australia is further behind: many launches here are existing managed funds converting to ETFs, and he estimates only about 8 to 9% of flows go into active ETFs. He expects that to grow.
4. Performance fees: only paid when they win
Savana's US small caps ETF (ASX: SVNP) is benchmarked against the S&P 600, the main US small companies index. As Evan described it, it charges a 1% management fee plus a performance fee that only applies when the fund beats its benchmark and is above its previous best since inception (a "high-water mark"). He expects the management fee to come down as the fund grows.
5. How the fund picks shares
The algorithm analyses around 60,000 listed companies every day and buys the 30 to 50 it sees as most undervalued. The portfolio is reviewed and rebalanced every two months, which Evan sees as the sweet spot between using fresh signals and giving cheap shares time to re-rate. He chose US small caps because it's a deep, liquid market where an algorithm's breadth is an advantage: a human analyst might cover 20 companies.
The idea behind it is collective intelligence: when a large, diverse group makes independent estimates, the errors cancel out and the average gets close to the truth. In Savana's jelly bean experiment, 1,600 beans were in the jar. The average person was about 600 out, but the average of everyone's guesses was within 2 to 3%. Savana looks for shares where that diversity of views breaks down: unloved companies, those covered by only one analyst, or ones dominated by a single news story.
6. How are active ETFs priced? The part most investors miss
This was the most interesting part of the conversation for me. When you buy an index ETF like A200, everyone knows what's inside: it holds the ASX 200. The market maker, the firm that stands ready to buy and sell the ETF on the ASX all day, can work out exactly what each unit is worth and quote prices close to that value.
But an active manager doesn't want to give away its whole portfolio every day. So how does anyone know what the ETF is worth? Evan explained there are three ways it's done in Australia:
Publish every holding every day, like an index ETF. Simple and transparent, but the manager gives away its ideas.
The fund makes its own market. Pioneered by Magellan around 2015. Evan's concerns: a possible conflict of interest, and only one market maker, so no competition on prices.
Publish enough every day for market makers to price it, but not the full recipe. The full portfolio comes out quarterly, two months late. This is Savana's approach and now the most common one.
Here's what surprised me. Under partial disclosure, Savana publishes its top five holdings and a sub-industry breakdown every day on its website, in a file called the "material portfolio information". And the market maker sees exactly the same information as you do. Nothing more.
So how can it price the ETF accurately? Market makers use sophisticated models. They fill in the gaps using how sectors and sub-industries move together, what the published holdings are doing and, when the US market is closed during our day, US futures and trading in Asia. The spread they quote (the gap between the buy and sell price) reflects how confident they are in their estimate.
“Market maker can see exactly what any investor can see.”Evan Metcalf, Executive Director, Savana
There's one more piece: the iNAV, or indicative net asset value. It's a live estimate of what each unit is worth, calculated through the day by an independent index provider (Solactive, in Savana's case). The index provider does see the full portfolio, but it doesn't trade, it only publishes the number.
The market maker can have a different view from the iNAV, because it's weighing hundreds of inputs while an iNAV provider might lean on one or two futures contracts when the US is closed. When we looked during the recording, SVNP's buy and sell prices were within about a cent or two of its iNAV of around $1.70. Evan said that's generally how it runs: around the iNAV, sometimes just outside.
- Check the iNAV on the issuer's website before you trade, and compare it with the price on your broker's screen.
- Use a limit order, not a market order, so you choose the most you'll pay or the least you'll accept.
- Watch the spread. A wide gap between buy and sell prices means the market maker is less sure, which can happen when the underlying market (here, the US) is closed.
- Know the disclosure model. Full, partial or none tells you how the fund is priced, and how much you can see of what you own.
7. Where ETFs go from here
The Australian ETF market is now around $400 billion. Evan has heard forecasts of $1 trillion to $1.5 trillion by 2030 and thinks the higher end isn't far wrong. He expects more active strategies, more new players, some consolidation and the closure of funds that don't attract money. He also sees AI having a big impact, both on financial advice and inside fund managers like Savana.
8. The thing people misunderstand about ETFs
Evan's answer was overlap. An investor holding an S&P 500 ETF, a Nasdaq ETF, VGS and a semiconductor ETF might own a couple of thousand companies, but still have something like 15% of their money in Nvidia and a few big tech names. Owning six or seven ETFs doesn't mean you're diversified. You can check yours, including direct shares, with our free ETF overlap calculator.
The key takeaway
Active ETFs are coming fast, and many of them won't show you everything they own every day. That's fine, as long as you understand how they're priced. Check the iNAV, use limit orders, and know whether the fund publishes its holdings in full, in part or not at all.
Watch the full interview on YouTube →
Products mentioned are examples discussed in the interview, not recommendations. Figures, fees and performance are as described by the guest at the time of recording and may have changed; check the PDS and the issuer's website. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. General information only: it doesn't consider your objectives, financial situation or needs.